She may have written this ten years ago, but I think it remains relevant even now. One evening at sundown, we were stopped in traffic at a railroad crossing in downtown Tucson while a freight train passed us, slowly gaining speed as it headed north to Phoenix. One again, Silko is not a logical or reasonable person in this case. From reading this article, it is evident that Silko needs to have more factual evidence like statistics to provide credibility to the reader. Skip to toolbar Sites at Penn State. They half-dragged her up into the trunk, but still she did not indicate any stowed-away human beings or illegal drugs. This is where her pathos was flawed, she took the example to a level I feel most people would not be able to relate to.
Silko’s use of pathos was very effective. I couldn’t count fast enough, but I saw 50 or 60 people headed north. Therefore, the article reads more like a series of anecdotes. Before the arrival of the Europeans, the indigenous communities throughout this region not only conducted commerce; the people shared cosmologies, and oral narratives about the Maize Mother, the Twin Brothers, and their grandmother, Spider Woman, as well as Quetzalcoatl, the benevolent snake. Her background has affected the way she perceives reality. After they satisfied themselves that he was not smuggling Chinese immigrants, they sent him on his way. Based in Tucson since , Leslie Marmon Silko has earned international attention for books like Ceremony, Storyteller, Laguna Woman, and Almanac of the Dead, the last a prophesy of the restoration of the Americas to their original inhabitants.
So we stepped out of the car and they motioned for us to stand on the shoulder of the road.
She includes stories and incidents that one would think to be sad. Silko poses an unbalanced argument which is more emotional than logical. They were dark young men, Indian and mestizo; they were smiling and a few of them waved at eseay in our cars.
In SeptemberElmer was convicted of reckless endangerment in a separate incident, for shooting at least 10 rounds from his M too close to a group of immigrants as they were crossing illegally into Nogales in March If you have any problems with writing, feel free to ask our writers for help! The Indian people of southern Mexico, of Guatemalaand those left in El Patorltoo, are still fighting for their lives and for their land against the cavalry patrols sent out by the governments of those lands.
Contextual analysis pays attention to what is going on in the world outside of this artifact and how it pertains to the artifact.
Summary of “The Border Patrol State” by Leslie Marmom Silko
Anna January 25, at 3: Unknown February 17, at 3: Silko and her companion Gus were traveling south from Albuqurgue when they were stopped by the border patrol. It was nearly midnight on New Mexico State Road 26, a dark, lonely stretch of two-lane highway between Hatch and Deming. Therefore, the article reads more like a series of anecdotes.
She compares her experience with a report she had read on the Argentine police officers who became addicted to interrogation, torture, and the murder that followed. Her thoughts were scattered and she lowers her credibility as a renowned author by giving examples that are unable to be properly sited and backed up. I am not partial to dogs, but I will always remember the small German shepherd that night.
Silko describes situations in which the Border Patrol pulls people over according to how they look. One again, Silko is not a logical or reasonable person in this case.
Based in Tucson sinceLeslie Marmon border patrol state silko essay Silko has earned international border patrol state silko essay attention for books like Ceremony, Storyteller, Laguna Woman, and Almanac of the Dead, the. Silko’s arguments in this article are one-sided. Silko’s article is unbalanced and not logical because there are too many personal experiences and not enough factual information. My parents came to the US because they wanted a better life for me. The roadblocks and checkpoints she describes are still up, doing a thriving business.
Textual analysis uses rhetorical terminology to try and draw people in.
English Silko Essay
Then one day when she stepped off the train in Albuquerque, two Border Patrolmen accosted her, wanting to know what she was doing, and why she was traveling botder Los Angeles and Albuquerque twice a month.
She presented identification and an explanation deemed suitable by the agents and was allowed to go about her business. Amrmon had settled back and gone to sleep while Gus drove, but I was awakened when I felt the car slowing to a stop. The men were violent with the small dog and became upset when she showed no borer in the inside of the car, so they dragged her to the trunk and then ordered her to staye their legs and feet.
The weird anger of these Border Patrolmen made me think about descriptions in the report of Argentine police and military officers who became addicted to interrogation, torture, and the murder that followed.
The agents ordered the two to step out of their vehicle. From reading this article, it is evident that Silko needs to have more factual evidence like statistics to provide credibility to the reader. Our cousin old Bill Pratt used to ride his horse miles overland from Laguna, New Mexico, to PrescottArizona, every summer to work as a fire lookout.
They half-dragged her up into tye trunk, but still she did not indicate any stowed-away human beings or illegal drugs. The only flaw with this example is when Silko goes as in depth when she discusses how she has a connection with the dog when she looks into her eyes. While politicians and multinational corporations extol the virtues of NAFTA and free trade in goods, not fleshthe ominous curtain is already up in a six-mile section at the border crossing at Mexicali; two miles are being erected but are not yet finished at Naco; and at Nogalesxtate miles south of Tucson, the steel leslis has been all rubber-stamped and awaits construction, likely to begin in March.