Wikipedia is a major presence on the electronic frontier, and the Wikipedia editors have been explicitly compared to the pioneers of Turner’s American frontier in terms of their youth, aggressiveness, boldness, equalitarianism and rejection of limitations. Social and economic developments took place almost daily and this directed Turner’s attention to the life of ordinary Americans from an early age. It was cause for the many popular, unrealistic portrayals of frontier women to emerge- either as helpless, fragile beings who needed their cowboy to come and rescue them, or the other extreme, a rough, tough, gun-toting wildcat like Annie Oakley. Kennedy in the early s explicitly called upon the ideas of the frontier. Each side, the Westerners and the native savages, struggled for mastery of the land through violence.
He also commented directly on the connections he saw between the past and the present. This is just an example, Ridge feels, of the widespread impact that the frontier thesis has had on American life. Philosophy of history , the study either of the historical process and its development or of the methods used by historians to understand their material. For many women, Asians, Mexicans who suddenly found themselves residents of the United States, and, of course, Indians, the West was no promised land. In her essay, she aimed to analyze Turner to find why he may have done this.
Both of these men used iconography—popular cultural images that, when seen by Americans, would incite certain ideas and feelings, especially of patriotism and nationalism.
Frontier land was practically free for the taking. Boles, “Turner, the frontier, and the study of religion in America,” Journal of the Early Republic 13 2 pp.
And his impact remains, reflected in many different fields, from professional scholarship to pop culture. It was cause for the many popular, unrealistic portrayals of frontier women to emerge- either as helpless, fragile beings who needed their cowboy to come wbout rescue them, or the other extreme, a rough, tough, gun-toting wildcat like Annie Oakley.
Each side, the Westerners and the native savages, struggled for mastery of the land through violence. As a result, Turner’s work gave rise to three new accurats Indeed, his influence was felt in American classrooms until the s and 80s. The Frontier Thesis or Turner Thesisis the argument advanced by historian Frederick Jackson Turner in that American democracy was formed by the American frontier.
The Frontier Debate
He held yet another point of view, differing from both Fhesis and Riley. Historians have noted that John F. They emphasized the values of individualism, empiricism, simplicity, equality, courage, discovery, theiss, and ffederick in the service of democratic access, human rights, ecological balance, and the resolution of social, economic, and political issues. While he agrees that the frontier was a place, not a process, he feels that Turner should not be as openly criticized as he has been by recent historians.
The West and the Myth. Turner never published a major book on the frontier for which he did 40 years of research. A Criticism of the Turner Theory”. Evidently, the belief that free political institutions of the United States spawned in ancient Germanic forests endured well into the s.
We also see it in the frontiers of knowledge or the frontier between two countries. White acknowledges that Turner left out certain elements—such as the Indians—but he does not use this as a reason to just dismiss what Turner had to say.
Help us improve this article! His explanation is incomplete on its own, given what we now know, but life on the frontier—cowboys, Indians, and railroads—provides mass entertainment today. As a public intellectual himself, Turner promoted the study of history. Individualism and love of liberty did bear the beginnings of American democracy whether or not these traits evolved of the frontier can be questioned, but Turner is highly convincing of this point. The influences of the frontier on American history were extensive.
These scouts also played a role in the disintegration of Native American strongholds in the western lands.
Worster, in his essay “New West, True West: Turner sets up the East and the West as opposing forces; as the West strives for freedom, the East seeks to control it. He traced the social evolution of frontier life as it continually developed across wccurate continent from the primitive conditions experienced by the explorer, trapper, and trader, through maturing agricultural stages, finally reaching the complexity of city and factory.
His “genius” and “divergent thinking” allowed Turner to break new ground with the presentation of his frontier thesis at the World Colombian Exposition.
He stressed the process—the moving frontier line—and the impact it had on pioneers going through the process.
Each of these played a vital role in the eventual mastering of the frontier wilderness; each would make provisions for those who would follow. This demonstrated the importance of the West at a time when scholars often paid more attention to the East. This development, in Turner’s description of the frontier, “begins with the Indian and the hunter; it goes on with the disintegration of savagery by the entrance of the trader Nevertheless, he made it clear that his historical writing was shaped by a contemporary agenda.
You can make it easier for us to review and, hopefully, publish your contribution by keeping a few points in mind. Turner represented the frontier view of academia, while Cody sought to entertain the public.